The 20 new players are ready to take on Nicaragua
| A tribal switch occurred in Episode 5. Those affected will have * (La Flor to Espada) or * (Espada to La Flor) beside their names |
 Dan Lembo Days: 37 (Jury #8) |
 Holly Hoffman Days: 38 (Jury #9) |
 Jane Bright* Days: 36 (Jury #7) |
 Jill Behm* Days: 18 (8th eliminated) |
 Jimmy Johnson Days: 8 (3rd eliminated) |
 Jimmy Tarantino Days: 11 (4th eliminated) |
 Marty Piombo* Days: 24 (Jury #2) |
 Tyrone Davis Days: 14 (5th eliminated) |
 Wendy Desmidt-Kolhoff Days: 3 (1st eliminated) |
 Yve Rojas Days: 15 (7th eliminated) |
 Alina Wilson* Days: 22 (Jury #1) |
 Ben Henry* Days: 32 (Jury #6) |
 Brenda Lowe Days: 27 (Jury #3) |
 Chase Rice* Days: 39 (Runner-Up) |
 Jud "Fabio" Birza Days: 39 (Winner) |
 Kelly Bruno Days: 15 (6th eliminated) |
 Kelly Shinn Days: 28 (Quit, Jury #5) |
 Matthew "Sash" Lenahan Days: 39 (3rd Place) |
 Naonka Mixon* Days: 28 (Quit, Jury #4) |
 Shannon Elkins Days: 6 (2nd eliminated) |