Blood is what ties loved ones together. Meet the new castaways out to discover more about the bonds that bind
| A tribe switch occurred in episode 5. Those affected will have * (Hunahpu -> Coyopa) or * (Coyopa -> Hunahpu) beside their names |
 Alec Christy* (Jury #5) |
 Baylor Wilson (Jury #7) |
 Dale Wentworth (6th eliminated) |
 Jaclyn Schultz Runner-Up) |
 John Rocker (3rd eliminated) |
 Josh Canfield* (Jury #1) |
 Nadiya Anderson (1st eliminated) |
 Val Collins (2nd eliminated) |
 Wes Nale* (Jury #3) |
 Drew Christy (4th eliminated) |
 Jeremy Collins (Jury #2) |
 Jon Misch* (Jury #6) |
 Julie McGee (Quit, 7th eliminated) |
 Keith Nale* (Jury #8) |
 Kelley Wentworth* (5th eliminated) |
 Missy Payne* (Third Place) |
 Natalie Anderson (Winner) |
 Reed Kelly (Jury #4) |