 Andrea Bohlke (Jury) |
 Ashley Underwood (Jury) |
 Francesca Hogi (Eliminated) |
 Grant Mattos (Jury) |
 Kristina Kell (Eliminated) |
 Matthew Elrod (Jury) |
 Natalie Tenerelli (Third Place) |
 Phillip Sheppard (Runner-Up) |
 Rob Mariano (Winner) |
16 new castaways seeking adventure in Nicaragua, 2 looking for ultimate redemption.
NOTES: Due to the structure of this season, only the player's status will be shown rather than elapsed days, either "Active", "Eliminated", "Awaiting Duel" (for those on Redemption Island), "Jury", "Runner-Up" or "Winner"
|
Andrea Bohlke (Jury) |
Ashley Underwood (Jury) |
Francesca Hogi (Eliminated) |
Grant Mattos (Jury) |
Kristina Kell (Eliminated) |
Matthew Elrod (Jury) |
Natalie Tenerelli (Third Place) |
Phillip Sheppard (Runner-Up) |
Rob Mariano (Winner) |
 David Murphy (Jury) |
 Julie Wolfe (Jury) |
 Krista Klumpp (Eliminated) |
 Mike Chiesl (Jury) |
 Ralph Kiser (Jury) |
 Russell Hantz (Eliminated) |
 Sarita White (Eliminated) |
 Stephanie Valencia (Eliminated) |
 Steve Wright (Jury) |